Where do we stand with 5-fluorouracil?

For nearly four decades, 5-fluorouracil (5-FU) has been the mainstay of treatment for colorectal cancer. Due to the lack of other agents with significant activity, tremendous efforts have been undertaken to increase the efficacy of 5-FU by investigating alternative schedules of delivery and biomodulation. However, bolus 5-FU in combination with folinic acid (FA), either as the Mayo Clinic or Roswell Park protocol, still represents the standard treatment for adjuvant and first-line palliative chemotherapy of colorectal cancer. In a recent metal analysis, infusional protocols of 5-FU demonstrated increased response rates (14% to 22%) and a marginal, but significant survival benefit of 3 weeks (11.3 to 12.1 months). In view of the much higher costs and complicated management of infusional 5-FU regimens, this marginal survival benefit does not yet allow protracted 5-FU application to be defined as standard therapy. However, protracted 5-FU infusion in combination with radiation can be considered standard therapy as adjuvant treatment of rectal cancer, since it has demonstrated a significant increase in survival. In the future, oral 5-FU prodrugs may be substituted for infusional 5-FU. Furthermore, current data indicate that 5-FU will also be an essential component of combination chemotherapy protocols with the new active agents oxaliplatin, irinotecan, and raltitrexed. Preclinical studies show synergistic antitumor activity of 5-FU with these agents, which corresponds well with clinical response rates of 50% in untreated and 15% to 25% in 5-FU- refractory patients. Moreover, 5-FU-based prodrug-active drug systems serve as excellent models for tumor-targeted gene therapy.