Efficient autocrine and paracrine signaling explain the osteogenic superiority of transgenic BMP-2 over rhBMP-2

Bone morphogenetic protein-2 (BMP-2) is an osteogenic protein used clinically to enhance bone healing. However, it must be applied in very high doses, causing adverse side effects and increasing costs while providing only incremental benefit. Preclinical models of bone healing using gene transfer to deliver BMP-2 suggest that transgenic BMP-2 is much more osteogenic than rhBMP-2. Using a reporter mesenchymal cell line, we found transgenic human BMP-2 cDNA to be at least 100-fold more effective than rhBMP-2 in signaling. Moreover, a substantial portion of the BMP-2 produced by the transduced cells remained cell associated. Signaling by transgenic BMP-2 occurred via binding to the type I receptor, activating the associated kinase and generating phospho-smads. Signaling was partially resistant to noggin, an important extracellular inhibitor of BMP-2, possibly because nascent BMP-2 binds to its cell surface receptor during secretion and thus signals in a protected peri-cellular environment. Although the amounts of BMP-2 secreted by the transduced cells were too low to affect distant cells, transduced cells were able to induce signaling in a paracrine fashion that required close proximity of the cells, possibly cell-to-cell contact. The greater osteogenic potency of transgenic BMP-2 was confirmed with human bone marrow stromal cells.